Statuses of issues on JIRA

Hi to all,

while I'm checking some issues on JIRA I have seen from the on-line  
help that it can be possible to add some more statuses to tracks in  
details the actual status of an issue.
I didn't know if this argument was already discussed but probably it  
can help the committers to see which patches can be reviewed.

These are the missing statuses in JIRA.

On Hold
     The issue is open but work on it is temporarily suspended until  
further feedback is received determining its resolution.
Continued
     The issue was on hold, and feedback was received indicating that  
further action are required towards its resolution.
Patch Available
     A patch for this issue has been uploaded to JIRA by a contributor.
Patch Reviewed
     A patch attached to this issue has been reviewed by another  
contributor.
Patch Revised
     A patch attached to this issue has been revised by the contributor.
Patch Finalized
     A patch attached to this issue is ready to be committed.
Ready To Review
     Issue is to be reviewed before resolving/closing


Thanks
Marco

[Jacques Le Roux]

I did a similar suggestion (but less documented, thanks to Jira updates and your research this is more clear now).
There has been not much interest, but this seems interesting and helpful to me. I must confess I'm a tools/gadgets addict (kind of
old geek perversion ;o) but strangely only with software.

Jacques

From: <[hidden email]>

> Hi to all,
>
> while I'm checking some issues on JIRA I have seen from the on-line
> help that it can be possible to add some more statuses to tracks in
> details the actual status of an issue.
> I didn't know if this argument was already discussed but probably it
> can help the committers to see which patches can be reviewed.
>
> These are the missing statuses in JIRA.
>
> On Hold
>     The issue is open but work on it is temporarily suspended until
> further feedback is received determining its resolution.
> Continued
>     The issue was on hold, and feedback was received indicating that
> further action are required towards its resolution.
> Patch Available
>     A patch for this issue has been uploaded to JIRA by a contributor.
> Patch Reviewed
>     A patch attached to this issue has been reviewed by another
> contributor.
> Patch Revised
>     A patch attached to this issue has been revised by the contributor.
> Patch Finalized
>     A patch attached to this issue is ready to be committed.
> Ready To Review
>     Issue is to be reviewed before resolving/closing
>
>
> Thanks
> Marco
>

[Vikas Mayur-3]

Not sure it would make sense to most of us but I will still go for it.

There should be no option to upload a patch on closed issue.
It could be achieved either by hiding Attach File/Screenshot  link on  
closed issue or by a pop up a message like "Can not attach a patch on  
closed issue. Do you want to open this issue? Yes No" .


Vikas


On Oct 17, 2008, at 1:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:

> I did a similar suggestion (but less documented, thanks to Jira  
> updates and your research this is more clear now).
> There has been not much interest, but this seems interesting and  
> helpful to me. I must confess I'm a tools/gadgets addict (kind of  
> old geek perversion ;o) but strangely only with software.
>
> Jacques
>
> From: <[hidden email]>
>> Hi to all,
>>
>> while I'm checking some issues on JIRA I have seen from the on-line
>> help that it can be possible to add some more statuses to tracks in
>> details the actual status of an issue.
>> I didn't know if this argument was already discussed but probably it
>> can help the committers to see which patches can be reviewed.
>>
>> These are the missing statuses in JIRA.
>>
>> On Hold
>>    The issue is open but work on it is temporarily suspended until
>> further feedback is received determining its resolution.
>> Continued
>>    The issue was on hold, and feedback was received indicating that
>> further action are required towards its resolution.
>> Patch Available
>>    A patch for this issue has been uploaded to JIRA by a contributor.
>> Patch Reviewed
>>    A patch attached to this issue has been reviewed by another
>> contributor.
>> Patch Revised
>>    A patch attached to this issue has been revised by the  
>> contributor.
>> Patch Finalized
>>    A patch attached to this issue is ready to be committed.
>> Ready To Review
>>    Issue is to be reviewed before resolving/closing
>>
>>
>> Thanks
>> Marco
>

[Jacques Le Roux]

Hi Vikas,

Do you think that this is available on the Jira version we use ? It's very minor anyway ;o)

Jacques

From: "Vikas Mayur" <[hidden email]>

> Not sure it would make sense to most of us but I will still go for it.
>
> There should be no option to upload a patch on closed issue.
> It could be achieved either by hiding Attach File/Screenshot  link on  
> closed issue or by a pop up a message like "Can not attach a patch on  
> closed issue. Do you want to open this issue? Yes No" .
>
>
> Vikas
>
>
> On Oct 17, 2008, at 1:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:
>
>> I did a similar suggestion (but less documented, thanks to Jira  
>> updates and your research this is more clear now).
>> There has been not much interest, but this seems interesting and  
>> helpful to me. I must confess I'm a tools/gadgets addict (kind of  
>> old geek perversion ;o) but strangely only with software.
>>
>> Jacques
>>
>> From: <[hidden email]>
>>> Hi to all,
>>>
>>> while I'm checking some issues on JIRA I have seen from the on-line
>>> help that it can be possible to add some more statuses to tracks in
>>> details the actual status of an issue.
>>> I didn't know if this argument was already discussed but probably it
>>> can help the committers to see which patches can be reviewed.
>>>
>>> These are the missing statuses in JIRA.
>>>
>>> On Hold
>>>    The issue is open but work on it is temporarily suspended until
>>> further feedback is received determining its resolution.
>>> Continued
>>>    The issue was on hold, and feedback was received indicating that
>>> further action are required towards its resolution.
>>> Patch Available
>>>    A patch for this issue has been uploaded to JIRA by a contributor.
>>> Patch Reviewed
>>>    A patch attached to this issue has been reviewed by another
>>> contributor.
>>> Patch Revised
>>>    A patch attached to this issue has been revised by the  
>>> contributor.
>>> Patch Finalized
>>>    A patch attached to this issue is ready to be committed.
>>> Ready To Review
>>>    Issue is to be reviewed before resolving/closing
>>>
>>>
>>> Thanks
>>> Marco
>>
>

[Vikas Mayur-3]

Hi Jacques, I do not see this feature available with the Jira version  
we use.

Yes these issues/features are minor and are not so important but same  
could be true with adding a comment and editing an issue that is  
closed :)


Vikas

On Oct 22, 2008, at 4:51 PM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:

> Hi Vikas,
>
> Do you think that this is available on the Jira version we use ?  
> It's very minor anyway ;o)
>
> Jacques
>
> From: "Vikas Mayur" <[hidden email]>
>> Not sure it would make sense to most of us but I will still go for  
>> it.
>> There should be no option to upload a patch on closed issue.
>> It could be achieved either by hiding Attach File/Screenshot  link  
>> on  closed issue or by a pop up a message like "Can not attach a  
>> patch on  closed issue. Do you want to open this issue? Yes No" .
>> Vikas
>> On Oct 17, 2008, at 1:19 AM, Jacques Le Roux wrote:
>>> I did a similar suggestion (but less documented, thanks to Jira  
>>> updates and your research this is more clear now).
>>> There has been not much interest, but this seems interesting and  
>>> helpful to me. I must confess I'm a tools/gadgets addict (kind of  
>>> old geek perversion ;o) but strangely only with software.
>>>
>>> Jacques
>>>
>>> From: <[hidden email]>
>>>> Hi to all,
>>>>
>>>> while I'm checking some issues on JIRA I have seen from the on-line
>>>> help that it can be possible to add some more statuses to tracks in
>>>> details the actual status of an issue.
>>>> I didn't know if this argument was already discussed but probably  
>>>> it
>>>> can help the committers to see which patches can be reviewed.
>>>>
>>>> These are the missing statuses in JIRA.
>>>>
>>>> On Hold
>>>>   The issue is open but work on it is temporarily suspended until
>>>> further feedback is received determining its resolution.
>>>> Continued
>>>>   The issue was on hold, and feedback was received indicating that
>>>> further action are required towards its resolution.
>>>> Patch Available
>>>>   A patch for this issue has been uploaded to JIRA by a  
>>>> contributor.
>>>> Patch Reviewed
>>>>   A patch attached to this issue has been reviewed by another
>>>> contributor.
>>>> Patch Revised
>>>>   A patch attached to this issue has been revised by the  
>>>> contributor.
>>>> Patch Finalized
>>>>   A patch attached to this issue is ready to be committed.
>>>> Ready To Review
>>>>   Issue is to be reviewed before resolving/closing
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Thanks
>>>> Marco
>>>
>>