Re: OFBIZ Manufacturing
Locked
 
|
Hi Jacques, all,
First of all: you are right. If there weren't a need for solution you wouldn't go that way. But as it happens, within the consortium of the project there are partners who have implemented ESB's (and for the sake of the argument let's pretend that in the European market space every variant ESB is implemented) and allow only to be connected through their ESB. And also the IMAGINE platform is expected to have an ESB as part of the architecture, but that hasn't been formalized yet. So that may change. So what needs to be done so that OFBiz can connect to an ESB and that info and data is delivered through that ESB to either the portal in the IMAGINE platform or the partner with his system at the other end of the ESB? Secondly: OFBiz is also a solution for manufacturing. We have the code in place. But how good is it? Are there endusers who use that component and how? I have seen and read the book you referred to, and have worked to the code to understand its principles. But like I said I don't have the experience in implementing a manufacturing solution, so I don't know what it all entails. That's why I invite everybody to share their insights. Regarding, Pierre Op 10 april 2012 23:39 schreef Jacques Le Roux <[hidden email] > het volgende: > Just a word: it does not make sense to use an ESB like ServiceMix as long > as it's not mandatory. In other words you may consider 1st using OFBiz as > much as possible, and use only an ESB if you need to integrate with other > systems. Even then sometimes using SOAP or XML-RPC would be easier > depending of the openness of third systems. RMI is faster but beware of > troubleshooting it on a net with a lot of firewalls... > > The beauty of OFBiz is that it comes already integrated. We know the ERP > way (all integrated) has some drawbacks, but don't forget about drawbacks > of other ways... OFBiz is not perfect but it works OOTB and can be "easily" > enhanced... Some ESB projects have already proved to fail in the mid/long > term... > > You might be interested by > https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBIZ/** > Manufacturing+Process+Stories+**and+Diagrams<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBIZ/Manufacturing+Process+Stories+and+Diagrams> > https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBADMIN/** > OFBiz+Related+Books#**OFBizRelatedBooks-<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBADMIN/OFBiz+Related+Books#OFBizRelatedBooks-> > "**GettingStartedwithApacheOFBizM**anufacturing&MRPin5EasySteps"(** > Release09.04andabove) > https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBREQDES/** > UBPL+Introduction<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/UBPL+Introduction> > https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBREQDES/** > Universal+Business+Process+**Library+Index<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/Universal+Business+Process+Library+Index> > > But this topic is more for the user list... > > Jacques > > From: "Integrin" <[hidden email]> > > Pierre - >> >> While I do not claim to be an expert in Manufacturing, I'm helping >> customize Ofbiz for a Food Sevices Industry in a Franchise Model where >> Ofbiz Manufacturing be the food kitchen; Additionally the following >> modules, being used >> - MyPortal : Dashboard >> - Order Manager: Purchase , Sales Orders, Transfer Orders >> - Party Manager : Suppliers, Users & Customers >> - SFA : Sales Forecast >> - Facility : Inventory & Shipping >> -Manufacturing: MRP in Manufacturing, very handy for automating >> Requirements management >> >> As far as ESB integration goes, Ofbiz being based on Service based >> Architecture, should come very handy; I'm guessing you will have some >> work to do to be able to make individual modules, loosely coupled >> using ESB >> >> Goodluck with your efforts! >> >> - Regards >> Sakthi >> >> On 4/10/12, Pierre Smits <[hidden email]> wrote: >> >>> Dear all, >>> >>> Currently I am participating in the collaboration project "IMAGINE - >>> Innovative End-to-End Management of Dynamic Manufacturing Networks", that >>> resides under the theme "Virtual Factories and Enterprises" as part of >>> the >>> FP7 Programme of the EU. >>> >>> The goal of this project is to enable SME Manufacturing Enterprises in >>> the >>> EU market space to shorten the time-to-market of their product by >>> assisting >>> manufacturing customers in forming partnerships with suppliers and a >>> better >>> exchange of information and data throughout the lifecycle of the >>> partnership. >>> >>> During methodology studies it is envisioned that exchange of information >>> and data entails 4 interlocking areas, namely: >>> >>> 1. Partner blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>> organization and human entities, including connection mechanisms >>> (addresses >>> and such) of the participating organization >>> 2. Manufacture blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>> products (e.g. pricing, QoS re delivery, mBOM's, eBOM's and such) >>> 3. End-2-End blueprints - All dynamic information (and data) re inputs >>> and output of the process segments, in customer to supplier end-2-end >>> processes while manufacturing the goods (but also including process >>> definitions in BPEL, BPMN and xPDL) >>> 4. QA blueprints - All information (and data) relating to maintaining >>> the QoS requirements of the organization and establishing/enhancing >>> trust >>> between (potential) partners (encompassing org. certification, e.g. ISO >>> 9000, but also product certification, and more) >>> >>> All to be facilitated through established Open Standards and Technolgies. >>> >>> In the methodology studies it was also envisioned that, while initial >>> profiling should start by registering company and lead contact persons >>> and >>> their mechanisms in a portal solution (currently intended OS product: >>> Liferay, part of the envisioned IMAGINE platform), as soon as the >>> connection mechanisms regarding service adapters are setup and verified >>> systems like CRM, Manufacturing, ProjectMgt and Warehousing connect >>> through >>> the IMAGINE platform (mainly OS ESB like Servicemix - while providing >>> dashboard functionalities in the portal for participants that are not >>> (yet) >>> at the highest level of maturity regarding partnering - e.g. uploading >>> data >>> through spreadsheets and info via PDF and such). >>> >>> As this project still has a lifespan of approx 2 years left and system >>> integration has no started yet, it is my belief that OFBiz could be in >>> the >>> front runner position and create a name in the EU market space regarding >>> Open Source ERP in general and Manufacturing in particular combined with >>> info and data exchange through ESBs. Which is a huge opportunity for us. >>> >>> Thinking of the possibilites I foresee following use-cases (amongst >>> others) >>> to be applicable: >>> >>> - When the initial registration of the company has been realized and >>> the >>> connection mechanism regarding the ESB connectivity has been setup and >>> verified the information relating the Partner blueprint is provided by >>> means of the data available/maintained in the Party component >>> - When potential suppliers are identified through the search >>> capabilities in the portal the data contained there (Party data et all) >>> is >>> pulled/delivered into the SCM (through the ESB) >>> - When potential customers are identified through the seach >>> capabilities >>> in the portal the data contained thee is pulled/delivered into the CRM >>> (through the ESB) >>> - When potential suppliers are initially contacted and a connection is >>> being negotiated more data is pullled from and/or delivered to Product >>> Catalog and Manufacturing (through the ESB) >>> - When an agreement is concluded this is also pulled/delivered in the >>> system of the participant(s) >>> - When proces segments are started, executed and concluded information >>> (date) thereabout are pulled/delivered into the ERP system of the >>> customer >>> (also through the ESB) and send to the portal for dashboarding >>> purpopes. >>> >>> Unfortunately I am not that well experienced in Manufacturing, >>> establishing >>> ESB integration for OFBiz and delivering data from one system (like >>> OFBiz) >>> through a third party ESB to another system (like OFBiz) and thus I am >>> wondering about possible difficulties regarding this. >>> >>> What do you think possible technical issues are given current state of >>> OFBiz? >>> >>> I appreciate and value your thoughts/input on this. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Pierre >>> >>> >> -- >> Sent from my mobile device >> > |
|
|
I prefer to connect OFBiz to ESB via REST.
Manufacturing works okay. I found a bug in the BOM that causes an out of memory error with large assemblies, but I haven't had time to fix it yet. -Adrian Quoting Pierre Smits <[hidden email]>: > Hi Jacques, all, > > > First of all: you are right. If there weren't a need for solution you > wouldn't go that way. > > But as it happens, within the consortium of the project there are partners > who have implemented ESB's (and for the sake of the argument let's pretend > that in the European market space every variant ESB is implemented) and > allow only to be connected through their ESB. > > And also the IMAGINE platform is expected to have an ESB as part of the > architecture, but that hasn't been formalized yet. So that may change. > > So what needs to be done so that OFBiz can connect to an ESB and that info > and data is delivered through that ESB to either the portal in the IMAGINE > platform or the partner with his system at the other end of the ESB? > > Secondly: > OFBiz is also a solution for manufacturing. We have the code in place. But > how good is it? Are there endusers who use that component and how? > > I have seen and read the book you referred to, and have worked to the code > to understand its principles. But like I said I don't have the experience > in implementing a manufacturing solution, so I don't know what it all > entails. That's why I invite everybody to share their insights. > > Regarding, > > Pierre > > > > > Op 10 april 2012 23:39 schreef Jacques Le Roux <[hidden email] >> het volgende: > >> Just a word: it does not make sense to use an ESB like ServiceMix as long >> as it's not mandatory. In other words you may consider 1st using OFBiz as >> much as possible, and use only an ESB if you need to integrate with other >> systems. Even then sometimes using SOAP or XML-RPC would be easier >> depending of the openness of third systems. RMI is faster but beware of >> troubleshooting it on a net with a lot of firewalls... >> >> The beauty of OFBiz is that it comes already integrated. We know the ERP >> way (all integrated) has some drawbacks, but don't forget about drawbacks >> of other ways... OFBiz is not perfect but it works OOTB and can be "easily" >> enhanced... Some ESB projects have already proved to fail in the mid/long >> term... >> >> You might be interested by >> https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBIZ/** >> Manufacturing+Process+Stories+**and+Diagrams<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBIZ/Manufacturing+Process+Stories+and+Diagrams> >> https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBADMIN/** >> OFBiz+Related+Books#**OFBizRelatedBooks-<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBADMIN/OFBiz+Related+Books#OFBizRelatedBooks-> >> "**GettingStartedwithApacheOFBizM**anufacturing&MRPin5EasySteps"(** >> Release09.04andabove) >> https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBREQDES/** >> UBPL+Introduction<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/UBPL+Introduction> >> https://cwiki.apache.org/**confluence/display/OFBREQDES/** >> Universal+Business+Process+**Library+Index<https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/Universal+Business+Process+Library+Index> >> >> But this topic is more for the user list... >> >> Jacques >> >> From: "Integrin" <[hidden email]> >> >> Pierre - >>> >>> While I do not claim to be an expert in Manufacturing, I'm helping >>> customize Ofbiz for a Food Sevices Industry in a Franchise Model where >>> Ofbiz Manufacturing be the food kitchen; Additionally the following >>> modules, being used >>> - MyPortal : Dashboard >>> - Order Manager: Purchase , Sales Orders, Transfer Orders >>> - Party Manager : Suppliers, Users & Customers >>> - SFA : Sales Forecast >>> - Facility : Inventory & Shipping >>> -Manufacturing: MRP in Manufacturing, very handy for automating >>> Requirements management >>> >>> As far as ESB integration goes, Ofbiz being based on Service based >>> Architecture, should come very handy; I'm guessing you will have some >>> work to do to be able to make individual modules, loosely coupled >>> using ESB >>> >>> Goodluck with your efforts! >>> >>> - Regards >>> Sakthi >>> >>> On 4/10/12, Pierre Smits <[hidden email]> wrote: >>> >>>> Dear all, >>>> >>>> Currently I am participating in the collaboration project "IMAGINE - >>>> Innovative End-to-End Management of Dynamic Manufacturing Networks", that >>>> resides under the theme "Virtual Factories and Enterprises" as part of >>>> the >>>> FP7 Programme of the EU. >>>> >>>> The goal of this project is to enable SME Manufacturing Enterprises in >>>> the >>>> EU market space to shorten the time-to-market of their product by >>>> assisting >>>> manufacturing customers in forming partnerships with suppliers and a >>>> better >>>> exchange of information and data throughout the lifecycle of the >>>> partnership. >>>> >>>> During methodology studies it is envisioned that exchange of information >>>> and data entails 4 interlocking areas, namely: >>>> >>>> 1. Partner blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>> organization and human entities, including connection mechanisms >>>> (addresses >>>> and such) of the participating organization >>>> 2. Manufacture blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>> products (e.g. pricing, QoS re delivery, mBOM's, eBOM's and such) >>>> 3. End-2-End blueprints - All dynamic information (and data) re inputs >>>> and output of the process segments, in customer to supplier end-2-end >>>> processes while manufacturing the goods (but also including process >>>> definitions in BPEL, BPMN and xPDL) >>>> 4. QA blueprints - All information (and data) relating to maintaining >>>> the QoS requirements of the organization and establishing/enhancing >>>> trust >>>> between (potential) partners (encompassing org. certification, e.g. ISO >>>> 9000, but also product certification, and more) >>>> >>>> All to be facilitated through established Open Standards and Technolgies. >>>> >>>> In the methodology studies it was also envisioned that, while initial >>>> profiling should start by registering company and lead contact persons >>>> and >>>> their mechanisms in a portal solution (currently intended OS product: >>>> Liferay, part of the envisioned IMAGINE platform), as soon as the >>>> connection mechanisms regarding service adapters are setup and verified >>>> systems like CRM, Manufacturing, ProjectMgt and Warehousing connect >>>> through >>>> the IMAGINE platform (mainly OS ESB like Servicemix - while providing >>>> dashboard functionalities in the portal for participants that are not >>>> (yet) >>>> at the highest level of maturity regarding partnering - e.g. uploading >>>> data >>>> through spreadsheets and info via PDF and such). >>>> >>>> As this project still has a lifespan of approx 2 years left and system >>>> integration has no started yet, it is my belief that OFBiz could be in >>>> the >>>> front runner position and create a name in the EU market space regarding >>>> Open Source ERP in general and Manufacturing in particular combined with >>>> info and data exchange through ESBs. Which is a huge opportunity for us. >>>> >>>> Thinking of the possibilites I foresee following use-cases (amongst >>>> others) >>>> to be applicable: >>>> >>>> - When the initial registration of the company has been realized and >>>> the >>>> connection mechanism regarding the ESB connectivity has been setup and >>>> verified the information relating the Partner blueprint is provided by >>>> means of the data available/maintained in the Party component >>>> - When potential suppliers are identified through the search >>>> capabilities in the portal the data contained there (Party data et all) >>>> is >>>> pulled/delivered into the SCM (through the ESB) >>>> - When potential customers are identified through the seach >>>> capabilities >>>> in the portal the data contained thee is pulled/delivered into the CRM >>>> (through the ESB) >>>> - When potential suppliers are initially contacted and a connection is >>>> being negotiated more data is pullled from and/or delivered to Product >>>> Catalog and Manufacturing (through the ESB) >>>> - When an agreement is concluded this is also pulled/delivered in the >>>> system of the participant(s) >>>> - When proces segments are started, executed and concluded information >>>> (date) thereabout are pulled/delivered into the ERP system of the >>>> customer >>>> (also through the ESB) and send to the portal for dashboarding >>>> purpopes. >>>> >>>> Unfortunately I am not that well experienced in Manufacturing, >>>> establishing >>>> ESB integration for OFBiz and delivering data from one system (like >>>> OFBiz) >>>> through a third party ESB to another system (like OFBiz) and thus I am >>>> wondering about possible difficulties regarding this. >>>> >>>> What do you think possible technical issues are given current state of >>>> OFBiz? >>>> >>>> I appreciate and value your thoughts/input on this. >>>> >>>> Regards, >>>> >>>> Pierre >>>> >>>> >>> -- >>> Sent from my mobile device >>> >> > |
Administrator
|
In reply to this post by Pierre Smits
Hi Jean-Luc, Pierre,
Just if you did not notice, thanks to Adrian, this discussion is now on user ML (does not belong me) Please use the new thread there: http://markmail.org/message/gnn5ardilphvu5e7 Jacques From: "Jean-Luc Malet" <[hidden email]> > Pierre, > > I agree with Jacques on this point. ESB could be a difficult solution to install and to maintain with different third system. I > think the SOAP and XML-RPC, that we already installed for our customers is a good way to do. > > For the other question, we have customers experiences on manufacturing system and we have a good knowledge and expertise about > manufacturing in general (most of them begun with BaaN ERP, in a manufacturing compagny) and also a good knowledge on the OFBiz > manufacturing functionnalities. We intalled one of our first customer, which was a manufacturing company, in 2006. And last week, > we installed another one which is a food manufacturing company. > > So don't hesitate to contact us if we can help and explain us how we could help you in this project. > > Regards, > > -- > Jean-Luc Malet > Directeur de Projet > Tel : 0974533612 > Mob : 0687618801 > > Société Néréide > 3b Les Isles 37270 Veretz > www.nereide.biz > > > > Le 10/04/2012 23:39, Jacques Le Roux a écrit : >> Just a word: it does not make sense to use an ESB like ServiceMix as long as it's not mandatory. In other words you may consider >> 1st using OFBiz as much as possible, and use only an ESB if you need to integrate with other systems. Even then sometimes using >> SOAP or XML-RPC would be easier depending of the openness of third systems. RMI is faster but beware of troubleshooting it on a >> net with a lot of firewalls... >> >> The beauty of OFBiz is that it comes already integrated. We know the ERP way (all integrated) has some drawbacks, but don't >> forget about drawbacks of other ways... OFBiz is not perfect but it works OOTB and can be "easily" enhanced... Some ESB projects >> have already proved to fail in the mid/long term... >> >> You might be interested by >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBIZ/Manufacturing+Process+Stories+and+Diagrams >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBADMIN/OFBiz+Related+Books#OFBizRelatedBooks-"GettingStartedwithApacheOFBizManufacturing&MRPin5EasySteps"(Release09.04andabove) >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/UBPL+Introduction >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/Universal+Business+Process+Library+Index >> >> But this topic is more for the user list... >> >> Jacques >> >> From: "Integrin" <[hidden email]> >>> Pierre - >>> >>> While I do not claim to be an expert in Manufacturing, I'm helping >>> customize Ofbiz for a Food Sevices Industry in a Franchise Model where >>> Ofbiz Manufacturing be the food kitchen; Additionally the following >>> modules, being used >>> - MyPortal : Dashboard >>> - Order Manager: Purchase , Sales Orders, Transfer Orders >>> - Party Manager : Suppliers, Users & Customers >>> - SFA : Sales Forecast >>> - Facility : Inventory & Shipping >>> -Manufacturing: MRP in Manufacturing, very handy for automating >>> Requirements management >>> >>> As far as ESB integration goes, Ofbiz being based on Service based >>> Architecture, should come very handy; I'm guessing you will have some >>> work to do to be able to make individual modules, loosely coupled >>> using ESB >>> >>> Goodluck with your efforts! >>> >>> - Regards >>> Sakthi >>> >>> On 4/10/12, Pierre Smits <[hidden email]> wrote: >>>> Dear all, >>>> >>>> Currently I am participating in the collaboration project "IMAGINE - >>>> Innovative End-to-End Management of Dynamic Manufacturing Networks", that >>>> resides under the theme "Virtual Factories and Enterprises" as part of the >>>> FP7 Programme of the EU. >>>> >>>> The goal of this project is to enable SME Manufacturing Enterprises in the >>>> EU market space to shorten the time-to-market of their product by assisting >>>> manufacturing customers in forming partnerships with suppliers and a better >>>> exchange of information and data throughout the lifecycle of the >>>> partnership. >>>> >>>> During methodology studies it is envisioned that exchange of information >>>> and data entails 4 interlocking areas, namely: >>>> >>>> 1. Partner blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>> organization and human entities, including connection mechanisms >>>> (addresses >>>> and such) of the participating organization >>>> 2. Manufacture blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>> products (e.g. pricing, QoS re delivery, mBOM's, eBOM's and such) >>>> 3. End-2-End blueprints - All dynamic information (and data) re inputs >>>> and output of the process segments, in customer to supplier end-2-end >>>> processes while manufacturing the goods (but also including process >>>> definitions in BPEL, BPMN and xPDL) >>>> 4. QA blueprints - All information (and data) relating to maintaining >>>> the QoS requirements of the organization and establishing/enhancing trust >>>> between (potential) partners (encompassing org. certification, e.g. ISO >>>> 9000, but also product certification, and more) >>>> >>>> All to be facilitated through established Open Standards and Technolgies. >>>> >>>> In the methodology studies it was also envisioned that, while initial >>>> profiling should start by registering company and lead contact persons and >>>> their mechanisms in a portal solution (currently intended OS product: >>>> Liferay, part of the envisioned IMAGINE platform), as soon as the >>>> connection mechanisms regarding service adapters are setup and verified >>>> systems like CRM, Manufacturing, ProjectMgt and Warehousing connect through >>>> the IMAGINE platform (mainly OS ESB like Servicemix - while providing >>>> dashboard functionalities in the portal for participants that are not (yet) >>>> at the highest level of maturity regarding partnering - e.g. uploading data >>>> through spreadsheets and info via PDF and such). >>>> >>>> As this project still has a lifespan of approx 2 years left and system >>>> integration has no started yet, it is my belief that OFBiz could be in the >>>> front runner position and create a name in the EU market space regarding >>>> Open Source ERP in general and Manufacturing in particular combined with >>>> info and data exchange through ESBs. Which is a huge opportunity for us. >>>> >>>> Thinking of the possibilites I foresee following use-cases (amongst others) >>>> to be applicable: >>>> >>>> - When the initial registration of the company has been realized and the >>>> connection mechanism regarding the ESB connectivity has been setup and >>>> verified the information relating the Partner blueprint is provided by >>>> means of the data available/maintained in the Party component >>>> - When potential suppliers are identified through the search >>>> capabilities in the portal the data contained there (Party data et all) >>>> is >>>> pulled/delivered into the SCM (through the ESB) >>>> - When potential customers are identified through the seach capabilities >>>> in the portal the data contained thee is pulled/delivered into the CRM >>>> (through the ESB) >>>> - When potential suppliers are initially contacted and a connection is >>>> being negotiated more data is pullled from and/or delivered to Product >>>> Catalog and Manufacturing (through the ESB) >>>> - When an agreement is concluded this is also pulled/delivered in the >>>> system of the participant(s) >>>> - When proces segments are started, executed and concluded information >>>> (date) thereabout are pulled/delivered into the ERP system of the >>>> customer >>>> (also through the ESB) and send to the portal for dashboarding purpopes. >>>> >>>> Unfortunately I am not that well experienced in Manufacturing, establishing >>>> ESB integration for OFBiz and delivering data from one system (like OFBiz) >>>> through a third party ESB to another system (like OFBiz) and thus I am >>>> wondering about possible difficulties regarding this. >>>> >>>> What do you think possible technical issues are given current state of >>>> OFBiz? >>>> >>>> I appreciate and value your thoughts/input on this. >>>> >>>> Regards, >>>> >>>> Pierre >>>> >>> >>> -- >>> Sent from my mobile device >> > > |
|
Administrator
|
In reply to this post by Pierre Smits
From: "Pierre Smits" <[hidden email]>
> Hi Jacques, all, > So what needs to be done so that OFBiz can connect to an ESB and that info > and data is delivered through that ESB to either the portal in the IMAGINE > platform or the partner with his system at the other end of the ESB? Hi Pierre, I had a small experience with Mule (between ElasticPath and OFBiz) in 2007. I will try to find some clues to you whenI will get a chance... I understood that an ESB is not your own recommendendation. My intention was to give you some elements to discuss with ESB zealots as long as OFBiz is enough for a general feature (an OFBiz application). On the other hand there are of course also good reasons to use an ESB when you get many protocols to handle between 3rd systems. If they are able offer SOAP or XML-RPC web services OOTB (like OFBiz does) this is then moot from an OFBiz POV. It would be great to have REST services as easy to use as are exported services at the moment... Jacques |
|
Administrator
|
In reply to this post by Jacques Le Roux
From: "Jacques Le Roux" <[hidden email]>
> Hi Jean-Luc, Pierre, > > Just if you did not notice, thanks to Adrian, this discussion is now on user ML (does not belong me) I meant (does not belong here), when it was on dev ML. I really wonder why I put me there :) Jacques > Please use the new thread there: http://markmail.org/message/gnn5ardilphvu5e7 > > Jacques > > From: "Jean-Luc Malet" <[hidden email]> >> Pierre, >> >> I agree with Jacques on this point. ESB could be a difficult solution to install and to maintain with different third system. I >> think the SOAP and XML-RPC, that we already installed for our customers is a good way to do. >> >> For the other question, we have customers experiences on manufacturing system and we have a good knowledge and expertise about >> manufacturing in general (most of them begun with BaaN ERP, in a manufacturing compagny) and also a good knowledge on the OFBiz >> manufacturing functionnalities. We intalled one of our first customer, which was a manufacturing company, in 2006. And last week, >> we installed another one which is a food manufacturing company. >> >> So don't hesitate to contact us if we can help and explain us how we could help you in this project. >> >> Regards, >> >> -- >> Jean-Luc Malet >> Directeur de Projet >> Tel : 0974533612 >> Mob : 0687618801 >> >> Société Néréide >> 3b Les Isles 37270 Veretz >> www.nereide.biz >> >> >> >> Le 10/04/2012 23:39, Jacques Le Roux a écrit : >>> Just a word: it does not make sense to use an ESB like ServiceMix as long as it's not mandatory. In other words you may consider >>> 1st using OFBiz as much as possible, and use only an ESB if you need to integrate with other systems. Even then sometimes using >>> SOAP or XML-RPC would be easier depending of the openness of third systems. RMI is faster but beware of troubleshooting it on a >>> net with a lot of firewalls... >>> >>> The beauty of OFBiz is that it comes already integrated. We know the ERP way (all integrated) has some drawbacks, but don't >>> forget about drawbacks of other ways... OFBiz is not perfect but it works OOTB and can be "easily" enhanced... Some ESB projects >>> have already proved to fail in the mid/long term... >>> >>> You might be interested by >>> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBIZ/Manufacturing+Process+Stories+and+Diagrams >>> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBADMIN/OFBiz+Related+Books#OFBizRelatedBooks-"GettingStartedwithApacheOFBizManufacturing&MRPin5EasySteps"(Release09.04andabove) >>> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/UBPL+Introduction >>> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/OFBREQDES/Universal+Business+Process+Library+Index >>> >>> But this topic is more for the user list... >>> >>> Jacques >>> >>> From: "Integrin" <[hidden email]> >>>> Pierre - >>>> >>>> While I do not claim to be an expert in Manufacturing, I'm helping >>>> customize Ofbiz for a Food Sevices Industry in a Franchise Model where >>>> Ofbiz Manufacturing be the food kitchen; Additionally the following >>>> modules, being used >>>> - MyPortal : Dashboard >>>> - Order Manager: Purchase , Sales Orders, Transfer Orders >>>> - Party Manager : Suppliers, Users & Customers >>>> - SFA : Sales Forecast >>>> - Facility : Inventory & Shipping >>>> -Manufacturing: MRP in Manufacturing, very handy for automating >>>> Requirements management >>>> >>>> As far as ESB integration goes, Ofbiz being based on Service based >>>> Architecture, should come very handy; I'm guessing you will have some >>>> work to do to be able to make individual modules, loosely coupled >>>> using ESB >>>> >>>> Goodluck with your efforts! >>>> >>>> - Regards >>>> Sakthi >>>> >>>> On 4/10/12, Pierre Smits <[hidden email]> wrote: >>>>> Dear all, >>>>> >>>>> Currently I am participating in the collaboration project "IMAGINE - >>>>> Innovative End-to-End Management of Dynamic Manufacturing Networks", that >>>>> resides under the theme "Virtual Factories and Enterprises" as part of the >>>>> FP7 Programme of the EU. >>>>> >>>>> The goal of this project is to enable SME Manufacturing Enterprises in the >>>>> EU market space to shorten the time-to-market of their product by assisting >>>>> manufacturing customers in forming partnerships with suppliers and a better >>>>> exchange of information and data throughout the lifecycle of the >>>>> partnership. >>>>> >>>>> During methodology studies it is envisioned that exchange of information >>>>> and data entails 4 interlocking areas, namely: >>>>> >>>>> 1. Partner blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>>> organization and human entities, including connection mechanisms >>>>> (addresses >>>>> and such) of the participating organization >>>>> 2. Manufacture blueprints - All static information (and data) re >>>>> products (e.g. pricing, QoS re delivery, mBOM's, eBOM's and such) >>>>> 3. End-2-End blueprints - All dynamic information (and data) re inputs >>>>> and output of the process segments, in customer to supplier end-2-end >>>>> processes while manufacturing the goods (but also including process >>>>> definitions in BPEL, BPMN and xPDL) >>>>> 4. QA blueprints - All information (and data) relating to maintaining >>>>> the QoS requirements of the organization and establishing/enhancing trust >>>>> between (potential) partners (encompassing org. certification, e.g. ISO >>>>> 9000, but also product certification, and more) >>>>> >>>>> All to be facilitated through established Open Standards and Technolgies. >>>>> >>>>> In the methodology studies it was also envisioned that, while initial >>>>> profiling should start by registering company and lead contact persons and >>>>> their mechanisms in a portal solution (currently intended OS product: >>>>> Liferay, part of the envisioned IMAGINE platform), as soon as the >>>>> connection mechanisms regarding service adapters are setup and verified >>>>> systems like CRM, Manufacturing, ProjectMgt and Warehousing connect through >>>>> the IMAGINE platform (mainly OS ESB like Servicemix - while providing >>>>> dashboard functionalities in the portal for participants that are not (yet) >>>>> at the highest level of maturity regarding partnering - e.g. uploading data >>>>> through spreadsheets and info via PDF and such). >>>>> >>>>> As this project still has a lifespan of approx 2 years left and system >>>>> integration has no started yet, it is my belief that OFBiz could be in the >>>>> front runner position and create a name in the EU market space regarding >>>>> Open Source ERP in general and Manufacturing in particular combined with >>>>> info and data exchange through ESBs. Which is a huge opportunity for us. >>>>> >>>>> Thinking of the possibilites I foresee following use-cases (amongst others) >>>>> to be applicable: >>>>> >>>>> - When the initial registration of the company has been realized and the >>>>> connection mechanism regarding the ESB connectivity has been setup and >>>>> verified the information relating the Partner blueprint is provided by >>>>> means of the data available/maintained in the Party component >>>>> - When potential suppliers are identified through the search >>>>> capabilities in the portal the data contained there (Party data et all) >>>>> is >>>>> pulled/delivered into the SCM (through the ESB) >>>>> - When potential customers are identified through the seach capabilities >>>>> in the portal the data contained thee is pulled/delivered into the CRM >>>>> (through the ESB) >>>>> - When potential suppliers are initially contacted and a connection is >>>>> being negotiated more data is pullled from and/or delivered to Product >>>>> Catalog and Manufacturing (through the ESB) >>>>> - When an agreement is concluded this is also pulled/delivered in the >>>>> system of the participant(s) >>>>> - When proces segments are started, executed and concluded information >>>>> (date) thereabout are pulled/delivered into the ERP system of the >>>>> customer >>>>> (also through the ESB) and send to the portal for dashboarding purpopes. >>>>> >>>>> Unfortunately I am not that well experienced in Manufacturing, establishing >>>>> ESB integration for OFBiz and delivering data from one system (like OFBiz) >>>>> through a third party ESB to another system (like OFBiz) and thus I am >>>>> wondering about possible difficulties regarding this. >>>>> >>>>> What do you think possible technical issues are given current state of >>>>> OFBiz? >>>>> >>>>> I appreciate and value your thoughts/input on this. >>>>> >>>>> Regards, >>>>> >>>>> Pierre >>>>> >>>> >>>> -- >>>> Sent from my mobile device >>> >> >> |
|
Administrator
|
In reply to this post by Jacques Le Roux
From: "Jacques Le Roux" <[hidden email]>
To: <[hidden email]> Sent: Thursday, April 12, 2012 8:41 AM Subject: Re: OFBIZ Manufacturing > From: "Pierre Smits" <[hidden email]> >> Hi Jacques, all, >> So what needs to be done so that OFBiz can connect to an ESB and that info >> and data is delivered through that ESB to either the portal in the IMAGINE >> platform or the partner with his system at the other end of the ESB? > > Hi Pierre, > > > I had a small experience with Mule (between ElasticPath and OFBiz) in 2007. I will try to find some clues to you whenI will get a > chance... Actually the mule machine was only used through HTTP engine as this time. Kind of REST if you want, it's another possibility This was used to sync promos, products, stocks, prices and giftcards SOAP has been improved these last times in OFBiz. I think it's now also good choice. Sorry I can't help you more on that part. It really depends on the environnement. ESBs are capable of using a lot of protocols. So you could also use JMS for instance. In OFBiz you can refer to serviceengine.xml for possible service engines. Someone in the team also created a MuleEngine. But I don't think it has been ever used. Jacques > I understood that an ESB is not your own recommendendation. My intention was to give you some elements to discuss with ESB zealots > as long as OFBiz is enough for a general feature (an OFBiz application). On the other hand there are of course also good reasons > to use an ESB when you get many protocols to handle between 3rd systems. If they are able offer SOAP or XML-RPC web services OOTB > (like OFBiz does) this is then moot from an OFBiz POV. > > It would be great to have REST services as easy to use as are exported services at the moment... > > Jacques |
|
|
Thanks all, for the heads up. It created some necessary insights. As soon
as architecture and system design evolve I will let you know more. Regards, Pierre Op 14 april 2012 14:00 schreef Jacques Le Roux <[hidden email] > het volgende: > From: "Jacques Le Roux" <[hidden email]> > To: <[hidden email]> > Sent: Thursday, April 12, 2012 8:41 AM > Subject: Re: OFBIZ Manufacturing > > > > From: "Pierre Smits" <[hidden email]> >> >>> Hi Jacques, all, >>> So what needs to be done so that OFBiz can connect to an ESB and that >>> info >>> and data is delivered through that ESB to either the portal in the >>> IMAGINE >>> platform or the partner with his system at the other end of the ESB? >>> >> >> Hi Pierre, >> >> >> I had a small experience with Mule (between ElasticPath and OFBiz) in >> 2007. I will try to find some clues to you whenI will get a chance... >> > > Actually the mule machine was only used through HTTP engine as this time. > Kind of REST if you want, it's another possibility > This was used to sync promos, products, stocks, prices and giftcards > > SOAP has been improved these last times in OFBiz. I think it's now also > good choice. > > Sorry I can't help you more on that part. It really depends on the > environnement. ESBs are capable of using a lot of protocols. So you could > also use JMS for instance. > In OFBiz you can refer to serviceengine.xml for possible service engines. > > Someone in the team also created a MuleEngine. But I don't think it has > been ever used. > > Jacques > > > I understood that an ESB is not your own recommendendation. My intention >> was to give you some elements to discuss with ESB zealots as long as OFBiz >> is enough for a general feature (an OFBiz application). On the other hand >> there are of course also good reasons to use an ESB when you get many >> protocols to handle between 3rd systems. If they are able offer SOAP or >> XML-RPC web services OOTB (like OFBiz does) this is then moot from an OFBiz >> POV. >> >> It would be great to have REST services as easy to use as are exported >> services at the moment... >> >> Jacques >> > |
«
Return to OFBiz - User
|
1 view|%1 views
| Free forum by Nabble | Edit this page |